Will My Homeowners Insurance Go Up If I File a Roof Claim?

Will a Roof Insurance Claim Raise Your Homeowners Insurance in Florida? (2025)

As a Florida homeowner, you already know insurance costs have become a serious financial burden. Since 2019, average homeowners’ insurance premiums have climbed more than 107%, reaching an average of $2,205 in 2025. When your roof gets damaged, the last thing you want is to make things worse by filing a claim that sends your premium even higher.

The honest answer is that filing a roof claim can raise your premium, but how much depends on several factors specific to your situation, your insurer, and Florida law. This article breaks down what to expect and how to protect yourself.

If you suffered roof damage and are either considering filing a claim or have already done so and are struggling to get fair payment, contact Landau Law for a free case review.

How Much Does Homeowners Insurance Go Up After a Roof Claim?

Filing a single roof claim can cause your homeowners insurance premium to increase by an average of 9% to 15%, though the actual number varies based on the type of claim, the payout amount, your location, and your insurer’s specific policies.

A few things make roof claims in Florida particularly costly to insurers, which affects how they price your policy afterward:

Roof claims are driving the industry. U.S. roof claims costs hit nearly $31 billion in 2024, up 30% from 2022. Roof-related damage now accounts for over 25% of all residential claim value nationwide, with wind and hail as the primary causes.

Roof age now carries more weight than ever. The premium gap between a home with a newer roof and one with a roof that is 11 to 15 years old was $49 in 2022. By 2025, that gap had grown to $155. If your roof is aging, expect your post-claim premium to reflect that more aggressively than it would have a few years ago.

Claims-free discounts can disappear. Many insurers offer discounts for policyholders who have not filed in several years. Filing a claim, even a small one, can eliminate that discount and result in a higher premium even if the direct rate increase is modest.

Not all claims trigger the same increase. A first-time claim on a named hurricane event is often treated more leniently than a routine claim or one filed shortly after another. Florida-specific laws also affect what insurers can and cannot do after you file.

Why Do Insurance Premiums Increase After a Claim?

Insurance companies use your claim history as one of their primary signals for how risky you are to insure. Here is how each factor plays into the rate calculation.

Claim History

The more claims you have on your record, the more an insurer views you as a high-risk policyholder. A single claim may result in a modest increase. Multiple claims within a few years can lead to steep increases or even non-renewal.

Severity of the Claim

A minor claim for storm-damaged flashing is treated differently than a full roof replacement. The higher the payout, the more the insurer adjusts your rate to offset the cost.

Type of Claim

In Florida, claims tied to named storms are sometimes handled separately from non-catastrophe claims. However, you should still expect a rate adjustment. If you live in a coastal or historically hurricane-prone area, insurers already price in elevated risk. A filed claim reinforces that risk profile.

Number of Claims

Filing multiple claims within a short window signals to underwriters that your property is prone to damage. Even if each individual claim is reasonable, the pattern matters.

How Florida’s Insurance Market Makes Roof Claims More Complicated

Florida has some of the most difficult homeowners insurance conditions in the country, and roof claims sit at the center of that problem.

Florida’s average homeowner insurance claim denial rate reached 46.7% in 2024, far above the national average. While Hurricane Milton drove much of that figure, it reflects a broader pattern of insurers aggressively limiting payouts.

Insurers Are Using AI and Satellite Imagery to Evaluate Your Roof

This is one of the most significant changes in the claims landscape over the past two years. Insurance carriers are now routinely using satellite imagery, drone assessments, and AI-driven tools to assess roof conditions before and after claims are filed. Many homeowners do not realize that an AI system may have already evaluated their roof from aerial photos and built a pre-claim baseline that the insurer will use to argue damage was pre-existing.

If AI flags your roof from a satellite photo, you have the right to request a human adjuster to verify the assessment. That right matters, and you should use it if your claim is denied or underpaid based on imagery you never agreed to.

Older Roofs Face Stricter Scrutiny

Florida law now allows insurance companies to require inspections for roofs 15 years or older. If the roof cannot demonstrate at least five years of remaining useful life, an insurer can deny coverage or refuse to renew the policy entirely. Many newer Florida policies also pay only Actual Cash Value for older roofs rather than Replacement Cost Value, meaning you receive the depreciated value of the roof rather than what it would actually cost to replace it today.

Filing Deadlines Are Strict

Under Florida Statute 627.70132, you have one year from the date of loss to file an initial claim and 18 months from the original date of loss for supplemental claims. For hurricane damage, the clock starts from the day the storm made landfall, not the day you noticed the damage. Missing these deadlines is one of the most commonly used grounds for denial, and insurers will enforce them.

Once you file, your insurer must acknowledge the claim within 7 days and conduct a physical inspection within 30 days of receiving your proof of loss.

How Long Will a Claim Affect Your Rates?

Most claims stay on your record for approximately five years. During that period, your rates may be higher than they would have been without the claim, though the impact typically fades as time passes. A first claim several years ago with no subsequent claims will carry much less weight than a recent claim or multiple claims in succession.

Some insurers offer claim forgiveness programs that limit or eliminate the rate impact of a first claim. If you have never filed before, it is worth asking your insurer whether this applies to your policy before you file.

When Are Insurers Not Allowed to Raise Your Rates?

There are specific situations where a rate increase should not follow a claim.

Basic inquiries. If you call your insurer to ask about whether something would be covered, that conversation should not be recorded as a claim or affect your premium. You have not filed anything.

Zero-dollar claims. If you file a claim but the insurer makes no payment, this is a zero-dollar claim. Your insurer should not raise your rate because they incurred no cost.

When Should You File a Roof Damage Claim?

The decision comes down to a few practical considerations.

First, confirm the damage is covered. Most Florida homeowners policies cover sudden wind, hail, or falling object damage. They do not cover gradual deterioration, wear and tear, or lack of maintenance. Knowing which category your damage falls into before you file can save you from a denial on your record.

Second, compare the repair cost to your deductible. If the repair is close to or less than your deductible, filing may not be worth it. You would pay most of the cost yourself and still have the claim on your record. Florida policies increasingly carry separate wind and hail deductibles that are percentage-based rather than flat amounts, sometimes as high as 5% of your home’s insured value. On a $400,000 home, that is $20,000 out of pocket before coverage kicks in.

Third, consider what a low settlement offer might mean. If an insurer’s adjuster significantly underestimates your damage, accepting that settlement locks you into a lower payout. Getting an independent estimate from a licensed roofing contractor before you accept anything is worth the time.

How Can a Florida Property Damage Lawyer Help With Your Roof Claim?

If your claim has been denied, underpaid, or dragged out without explanation, you are not without options. A Florida property damage lawyer can review your policy, evaluate whether the denial was proper, and take action if your insurer is not holding up its end of the contract.

At The Landau Law Group, we handle property damage claims throughout Florida. Here is what we can do for your roof claim:

• Review your policy. Insurance policies are written to be difficult to interpret. We will go through yours and identify what coverage you are actually entitled to and whether the insurer has honored it.
• Assist with documentation. Strong claims require thorough documentation. We help clients gather photos, contractor estimates, inspection reports, and any other materials needed to support the claim.
• Negotiate on your behalf. Insurers have legal teams working to limit payouts. We negotiate directly with the insurer to pursue the settlement your damage warrants.
• Take the case to court if necessary. If the insurer refuses to pay what is owed, we will file suit and represent you through litigation.

If you suffered roof damage and are thinking about filing a claim, or have already filed and are running into problems, contact Landau Law today for a free case review.

Property Damage Blog Posts